The worst franchise in pro sports:
2009: Pittsburgh Pirates .. Tom Jones, St. Petersburg Times
2008: Pittsburgh Pirates .. Dave Golokhov, Fox Sports/AskMen
2007: Pittsburgh Pirates .. Larry Dobrow, CBS Sports
What’s the difference between Dobrow’s annual ‘I hate the Bucs’ hammering, the 2008 award, and the one we just received this year?
Not much, you say? Think again.
Not only has Tom Jones been writing sports longer than the twenty-two years John Perrotto has covered the Pirates, that piece he just wrote is in one of the nation’s better newspapers which also happens to be in one of the other MLB markets.
Ouch.
Now consider some of his words:
Whenever they do draft and develop a star, they end up trading him. They’ve become almost a farm system for the big-market teams such as the Yankees and Red Sox. They’ve gone 17 seasons without a winning record, and it wouldn’t be surprising to see them go at least another 17. (emphasis supplied by Bucco Blog)
Thank you Mr. Jones – that’s good stuff. He’s right .. it wouldn’t be surprising considering the way we’re headed.
After the 2007 season the Pittsburgh Pirates had the 26th best farm system in baseball, according to Baseball America. Now after two years of intense salary dumping, trades, and other giveaways under the new regime, Jim Callis told me where we are ranked:
I really haven’t tried to break the organizations down vs. each other, but 20th or so is probably fair. They’ve added some depth but lost McCutchen. Really hard to say — I haven’t been impressed with many of the NL systems I’ve edited so far.
The only player who has graduated to a full-time job from our 2007 system is Andrew McCutchen and he was replaced in the system by Pedro Alvarez after the 2008 draft. In other words, after Neal Huntington and Frank Coonelly gutted more than half of our 25-man roster they inherited by trading 14 players for 26 and netting 131 years of control, and after spending the most money in the game in the first year draft the last two years mostly on risky high school arms and Alvarez, we’ve barely moved up the stocked talent ladder.
Barely moved.
I hear you starting to form an argument – Baseball America ranks organizations by established impact talent instead of trying to decipher potential upside of, say, high school pitchers just taken in the last draft who may or may not ever amount to anything. That’s fair – I think BA does a good job of intermixing the two myself, but let’s take your argument one step further.
I pressed Callis where the Pirates would rank today if they had taken Maztek, Wheeler, or Green over Sanchez last year, signed Scheppers in 2008, and inked Sano this year:
Maybe the top ten.
And that is the crux of my argument here – we can’t afford to be making these kind of mistakes. Argue all you want that Scheppers wasn’t healthy or was only throwing 80% in his bullpen in front of Huntington, argue all you want about Rob Plummer’s tough policy on Sano, Rene Gayo’s flagrant aggressiveness with the family, or whether or not we knew he was 16 or 21, and argue all you want about the merits of filling a position of need instead of taking the best available in the first year draft. Those might be valid points.
My point is that we didn’t get take the right risks – we failed to give Plummer upfront what Sano wanted, we spent $4 million on Ramon Vazquez instead of using Bixler and taking a $1.5 million risk on Scheppers, and I don’t even have to tell you how ludicrous it was to take Sanchez over impact players in last year’s draft simply to fill an organizational hole. Failing to take those risks has left us just as deep in the hole as we were two and one-half years ago, although you could also argue the Nuttings can now field cheaper rosters for several seasons with all the years of control we gained.
We’re not getting the job done.
Where we failed – instead of confronting the fan base and telling them that there would be a six-year rebuilding stage starting in late 2007 regardless of the fallout, we focused on supplementing our short-term major league roster in our acquisitions instead of acquiring significantly higher rated talent in the lower levels of the organization aiding the long-term plan.
We failed to take the right risks.
That was a colossal error which the results from are just starting to be seen, like in BA”s organizational rankings. And while BA’s work isn’t proof-positive of anything, it’s the best information the fans have available. Ask Frank Coonelly – he cites them to us as well. And down the road it will be seen in mediocre win rates like we saw across our system last year because every other club in our division has something we don’t have – a better stocked farm system or money to burn.
We can’t continue these misses or what Tom Jones said above will happen – we’ll still be here 17 years from now wondering where it all went wrong.
–
I am stunned that some of the Pittsburgh Pirates fan base participated in a chat at the Post-Gazette partially designed to give the newspaper a fleeting edge on what to put behind a pay wall to force the fans to pay for.
Why would anyone provide the means for another person to take money out of their pocket? D’uh. Maybe I’m just starting to understand the real reason the Pirates sold 1.6 million tickets last year.
I understand the industry is dying but instead of adapting they are trying to force change. What did I say last night happens when change is forced? That’s right, it inevitably fails. Counting on the remaining Pittsburgh Pirates fan base to help a newspaper survive is about as shaky a plan as it comes because you know who is going to beat them to the punch?
These guys, and these guys, and these guys, just to name a few.
Wake up people.
–
Speaking of fluff that needs to go behind a pay wall so we don’t have to view it any more, what the hell was Smizik thinking in this piece? Maybe he should spend some of his time digging in Federal Street’s dumpsters instead since he’d probably get more information from that rat hole than he will from the Nuttings? Yeah baby, we need a pay wall up in Pittsburgh alright.
If it ‘aint fit to print, it ‘aint fit to read.
–
Dejan reports we’re looking to add another Rule 5 pick.
Oh, happy days are here again
The skies above are clear again
So, Let’s sing a song of cheer again
Happy times
Happy nights
Happy days
Are here again!
–
Speaking of happier days:
PROFESSIONAL PITCHING LESSONS: Ex-Major League Baseball player with the Pittsburgh Pirates residing in Charleston [SC] available for pitching lessons. Contact Brian Rogers, ***-***-****.
–
One happy dude. He loves the attention, obviously. But good for him, he’s earned the right to have it.
–
Like the NEWS section above? Wish it had different links, more links, different stuff? It’s simply an RSS aggregator and many of the links are quiet right now like with our affiliates. But give me your ideas for a one-stop Pirates news hole.
How about the new comment rating system? I think it’s lame myself but several folks have asked for it and I’m willing to try it out. Let me know what you think.



